It’s October, aka spooky reading season, and how could I let this month pass by without reading the new Stephen King novel? I’m not a die-hard fan; he’s far too prolific for me to have read most of his stuff, but I do enjoy a King novel here and there, and despite its 400 pages, I raced through Holly in a matter of days. I don’t want to give away any spoilers here, but it doesn’t take too far long into the book before you realize what the ‘horror’ element is. Once this is revealed, it’s more of a mystery, a detective procedural and work of suspense, something I wasn’t really expecting from King this time around.

Plot Summary

Holly Gibney is a private investigator belonging to a detective agency by the name of Finders Keepers, which she shares with her partner, Pete. Holly is an odd woman who King fans will be familiar with if they’ve read his last few books, where Holly makes an appearance. This is the first I’ve met her, and other than a few references to previous horrors in her life, there is no reason you need to read those books before enjoying this one. In this novel we meet her during Covid, watching her mother’s funeral on zoom. This story jumps between time periods, starting in 2012, and ending in July of 2021. Holly is hired by a distressed mother whose 24-year-old daughter Bonnie has been missing for almost a month. A note was left taped on her bike that said “I’ve had enough” but her mother suspects this was placed there by a kidnapper. As Holly investigates, she begins to discover other missing persons cases in the same area and suspects a link to Bonnie’s case. Shortly after the book begins, the reader is introduced to the kidnapper, and discovers exactly what is happening to these missing people, and why. So rather than a mystery this is a work of suspense that prompts us to cheer Holly on the closer she gets to solving the case.

My Thoughts

As I mentioned in my previous review of a King novel from a few years ago, his political views are well on display here. In the course of her investigation Holly meets many strangers, sometimes for only a few minutes at a time. But because Holly is a bit of a hypochondriac (her words), she’s very careful about wearing her mask at all times, only touching elbows, using gloves to touch takeout food containers, etc. Her precautions prompt those around her to comment on the situation, some assuring her she’s being duped by a hoax, while others mock her openly, while others still are happy to comply with her wishes. Before hear death Holly’s mother was a big supporter of Donald Trump who refused to get vaccinated, claiming (until she got placed on a ventilator) that she didn’t have Covid, and simply had the flu. Understandably this Covid death puts Holly in a position of defensiveness, but she keeps her opinions to herself when people are lecturing her on their own views of the pandemic. Some may view this as King taking advantage of a reader’s undivided attention to push his own political views, but I see this more as an accurate pulse-taking of the country at that time. People turned the pandemic into a political issue, and most had strong views on both sides – King is simply reflecting that reality back at us.

Race, class and sexual identity other issues that King touches upon, although he doesn’t wade into them as deeply as the pandemic. Most of the victims are white, middle class and heterosexual, but when a few disappear who don’t fit that profile, their cases are treated by very differently by law enforcement, as well as the general public. Assumptions are made about their disappearances, and the length of time they are searched for varies. Some of the victims are never presumed missing at all, simply because they had no one look for them.

So was this book scary? It doesn’t involve any supernatural elements; all the horror is based in human cruelty, but it’s still hard to believe. Like many crime procedurals, instead, we are horrified at the ways in which we treat each other. Stephen King has written over 60 books, and no doubt he has discovered the they scariest thing he can write about is simply us, and the darkest parts of our personalities.

Get my top 25 book recommendations

Sign up to get the download as well as an email sent once a month with links to my latest reviews, information on my online book club, and other bookish announcements.

Check your inbox for the link!